Contradictions in HIMS Psych Reports: One Pilot's Experience
“Did not report tremors” — or did he?
June 4, 2025 — Pilots for HIMS Reform News
In response to our recent article on subjectivity in psychiatric evaluations, one aviation technician reached out to share his experience navigating the HIMS psychiatric process — and the contradictions it revealed.
Jonathan Wilder, an NCATT Certified Aircraft Electronics Technician, described conflicting statements found in his FAA HIMS Psychiatric Report authored by the psychiatrist. In one section of the report, the psychiatrist wrote:
“He did not report hand tremors or visual hallucinations.”
However, in the section titled “Regulatory Components” under “Manifestation of Withdrawal Symptoms,” the same report later states:
“He did report alcohol withdrawal hand tremors.”
According to Mr. Wilder, the word “not” in the first sentence was clearly underlined, making it unlikely to be a typo or oversight.
This example underscores the broader concern voiced by many pilots and professionals — that psychiatric evaluations in the HIMS program often rely on subjective language, inconsistent observations, and documentation that lacks accountability.
We thank Mr. Wilder for sharing his story. If you have an experience to share, contact us.